Access Barriers and Institutional Inclusion Shape University Platform

Access Barriers and Institutional Inclusion Shape University Platform

The OER Observatory aggregates and displays OER-related news and content from third-party sources worldwide. This content is not produced by UNESCO or the OER Dynamic Coalition. All rights and responsibility for the original content remain with the respective authors and publishers. The inclusion of third-party content in the Observatory does not imply endorsement by UNESCO or the OER Dynamic Coalition. Users can access the original source through the link provided with each item.

A cross-sectional investigation examining how university students perceive digital access barriers, institutional inclusion, and platform usability found that personal obstacles and campus support jointly explain forty-three percent of the variance in platform usability scores. Conducted among 304 undergraduate and graduate students at universities in the Russian Federation, the study showed that while students perceived relatively low access barriers, their evaluation of their university's digital platform averaged 62.40 on the System Usability Scale. This rating fell below the widely recognized benchmark of 68, placing platform usability at the borderline between marginal and acceptable utility. Concurrently, participants rated institutional digital inclusion above the midpoint, averaging 3.44 on a five-point scale, whereas perceived access barriers averaged 2.14. Access barriers and institutional inclusion contributed with comparable strength to usability evaluations, beyond age and gender.

The expansion of information and communication technologies has established learning management systems as central components of modern higher education, bridging classroom instruction with flexible remote coursework. In the Russian Federation, national initiatives like the Digital Educational Environment project have directed substantial investment toward upgrading technical infrastructure and expanding students' digital competencies. Nonetheless, literature indicates that persistent disparities in accessibility and usability still affect how students engage with digital platforms, varying across geographic regions, campus infrastructures, and individual prior experience. The researchers observed that previous investigations often examine usability in isolation or treat accessibility strictly as technical standards compliance for students with disabilities. Drawing upon the Information Systems Success Model and Universal Design for Learning principles, this study evaluated how student access barriers, institutional support, and platform usability interrelate within a general university population.

The authors formulated six explicit hypotheses testing bivariate associations, group differences, and multivariable predictions among the three core constructs. Hypotheses one through three proposed that perceived access barriers would correlate negatively with platform usability and institutional digital inclusion, while institutional inclusion would correlate positively with usability. Hypothesis four anticipated significant gender differences in perceived institutional inclusion, while hypothesis five predicted that inclusion and usability ratings would differ significantly by daily digital device screen time. Hypothesis six posited that access barriers and institutional inclusion would significantly predict platform usability after controlling for age and gender. The research team emphasized that their quantitative cross-sectional design operationalized subjective self-reports regarding student obstacles, current institutional support practices, and direct platform usability, rather than auditing objective web accessibility or measuring classroom pedagogical techniques directly.

Data were gathered through a voluntary online questionnaire administered between May 8 and May 16, 2026, yielding valid responses from 304 students. The sample comprised 159 male students (52.3 percent) and 145 female students (47.7 percent). Valid age entries from 299 participants revealed a mean age of 21.51 years (SD = 6.45, range 17 to 52). Undergraduates spanned all four study years -- first-year (25.7 percent), second-year (20.4 percent), third-year (14.5 percent), and fourth-year (20.4 percent) -- alongside graduate students (19.1 percent). Domestic students comprised 89.5 percent and international students 10.5 percent. Geographically, 90.8 percent of respondents studied in the Republic of Tatarstan: 232 students (76.3 percent) attended a technological university in Almetyevsk enrolled primarily in petroleum engineering, while 44 students (14.5 percent) attended a federal university in Kazan. Twenty-three students attended Moscow universities, and five did not specify an institution.

To evaluate access barriers and institutional support, the researchers adapted the Barriers to Digital Access and Digital Inclusion subscales from the Questionnaire for Digital Equity and Accessibility in Higher Education, originally developed by Amjad and colleagues. Each adapted subscale contained ten items rated on a five-point agreement scale. The digital inclusion items were deliberately reworded to measure active practices currently implemented by the students' universities rather than prospective inclusion measures. The instruments underwent rigorous Russian translation and independent back-translation, with discrepancies resolved by subject-matter experts. Psychometric testing indicated strong internal consistency in the sample, showing Cronbach's alpha values of 0.85 for access barriers and 0.91 for digital inclusion (McDonald's omega of 0.86 and 0.92). Confirmatory factor analyses demonstrated acceptable though marginal single-factor fit, supporting composite scale scores.

Platform usability was measured using John Brooke's standardized ten-item System Usability Scale, which features five positively phrased and five negatively phrased statements scored from 1 to 5. Responses were converted according to Brooke's formula -- subtracting one from positive item scores, subtracting negative scores from five, and multiplying the overall sum by 2.5 to yield a 0 to 100 composite index. The scale exhibited strong internal consistency, with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.87 and an omega of 0.87. Confirmatory factor analysis indicated marginal single-factor fit (CFI = 0.88, SRMR = 0.069, RMSEA = 0.115). Across the full sample, the mean usability score was 62.40 (SD = 15.60), falling below Bangor and colleagues' benchmark of 68. Students agreed most strongly that most people would learn the system quickly (M = 3.63), while agreement was lowest regarding needing technical support (M = 2.34).

Item-level results for the Barriers to Digital Access scale demonstrated that student obstacles clustered around financial constraints and localized training deficits rather than core technical connectivity. The two items drawing the highest agreement were financial limitations preventing hardware acquisition, such as laptops or smartphones (M = 2.47, SD = 1.03), and inadequate digital literacy resources within students' local residential areas (M = 2.47, SD = 0.92). Power outages disrupting distance learning averaged 2.25, while data costs recorded a mean of 2.14. Conversely, students reported low levels of difficulty regarding lacking means to participate in distance education (M = 1.87), cultural or linguistic barriers (M = 1.91), and inadequate campus digital integration infrastructure (M = 1.96). Reverse-scored home internet reliability averaged 2.13, indicating that most students possessed stable home internet access.

On the institutional Digital Inclusion subscale, student evaluations indicated that universities succeeded in expanding digital content and technical support services, while falling short in direct material provision. The highest-rated institutional practice was expanding access to open educational resources, with an item mean of 3.83 (SD = 0.83). Maintaining stable infrastructure for uninterrupted distance learning and providing accessible online technical support each averaged 3.59. Peer support networks recorded a mean of 3.52, while multilingual resources, subsidized internet access, and digital literacy programs each averaged 3.48. In contrast, institutional measures addressing physical device affordability received the lowest endorsement: partnerships with technology firms to offer hardware and software discounts averaged 3.07, and institutional initiatives providing affordable digital devices recorded the lowest mean on the subscale at 3.00 (SD = 1.13).

Bivariate correlational analysis using Pearson product-moment coefficients confirmed all hypothesized relationships among access barriers, institutional inclusion, and platform usability. Across 299 participants with complete age data, barriers to digital access exhibited a significant negative correlation with institutional digital inclusion (r = -0.42, 95% CI [-0.51, -0.32], p < 0.001), supporting hypothesis three. Access barriers were also significantly and negatively associated with system usability scores (r = -0.55, 95% CI [-0.63, -0.47], p < 0.001), validating hypothesis one. Concurrently, institutional inclusion correlated significantly and positively with usability ratings (r = 0.55, 95% CI [0.46, 0.62], p < 0.001), confirming hypothesis two. Age exhibited no significant correlation with perceived access barriers (r = -0.01) or platform usability (r = -0.05), and showed only a weak negative correlation with institutional digital inclusion (r = -0.12, p = 0.041).

Subgroup comparisons revealed significant differences across gender and daily device screen time. Independent-samples t-tests revealed no significant gender differences in perceived access barriers (t = 0.69, p = 0.490) or platform usability ratings (t = 0.83, p = 0.406). However, perceived digital inclusion differed significantly by gender, with male students reporting higher institutional inclusion (M = 3.58, SD = 0.79) than female students (M = 3.29, SD = 0.69; t = 3.34, p = 0.001, Cohen's d = 0.38), supporting hypothesis four. Furthermore, one-way ANOVA across 301 students showed that daily digital device use was significantly related to institutional inclusion (F = 6.17, p < 0.001) and platform usability (F = 2.86, p = 0.024), supporting hypothesis five. Post hoc Tukey tests demonstrated that students using devices over six hours daily reported significantly lower inclusion (M = 2.96) and usability (M = 55.27) than classmates using devices between one and four hours daily.

To test hypothesis six, the researchers performed a hierarchical multiple linear regression predicting usability scores across 299 students. The first block entering age and gender was not significant, accounting for only 0.4 percent of variance. Adding barriers to digital access and institutional inclusion in the second block significantly improved model fit (ΔR2 = 0.43, p < 0.001), explaining 43 percent of total variance (adjusted R2 = 0.42). Access barriers negatively predicted usability (B = -10.24, β = -0.39, sr2 = 0.125, p < 0.001), while institutional inclusion positively predicted usability (B = 7.94, β = 0.39, sr2 = 0.117, p < 0.001).

The authors emphasized that these findings represent cross-sectional statistical associations rather than causal effects, cautioning that unmeasured factors like digital screen fatigue might explain lower ratings among heavy device users. Several methodological limitations frame these results. The convenience sample was heavily concentrated in one technological university in Almetyevsk, limiting nationwide generalizability. Furthermore, adapted scales exhibited marginal confirmatory factor fit, usability evaluations pertained to students' own institutional platforms, and the study did not record disability status or evaluate objective Web Content Accessibility Guidelines compliance.

Subject of Research: University student perceptions of digital access barriers, institutional digital inclusion, and educational platform usability

Article Title: University students' perceptions of digital access barriers, institutional digital inclusion, and platform usability in digital learning environments

Article References: Salakhova, V. B., Babieva, N. S., Melnik, M. V., Khafizova, A. A., Egorova, L. A., & Blinova, S. A. (2026). University students' perceptions of digital access barriers, institutional digital inclusion, and platform usability in digital learning environments. Frontiers in Computer Science, 8, 1991196. https://doi.org/10.3389/fcomp.2026.1991196

Image Credits: AI Generated

Keywords: digital access barriers, digital inclusion, platform usability, System Usability Scale, higher education, learning management systems, educational technology, digital equity, Russian Federation, university students, cross-sectional survey, hierarchical multiple regression, daily device screen time, digital literacy, open educational resources, Universal Design for Learning, gender differences in education, educational infrastructure